The King of Quacks

The blog · 7 min read

Why Miracle Cures Work on Us: What Doc Springer Understood About the Mind

Springer's customers weren't fools. Placebo responses, regression to the mean, testimonials and trust all made his teas and crystals feel like they worked. The same tricks still sell today.

AI-generated image · artistic interpretation, not a photograph

It's easy to laugh at the people who mailed money to Curtis Howe Springer. The National Park Service says he shipped more than four million packages from Zzyzx over thirty years: herb teas, "Nerve Cell Food," "Hollywood Pep Cocktail." A former employee described Springer's formula as 10 percent crust from Soda Lake and 90 percent Epsom salts. Who falls for that?

The honest answer is: almost everyone, under the right conditions. Springer's customers were not stupid. They were people, and the human mind has predictable weak spots. He seems to have understood several of them by instinct. Here are the main ones, and how they still work.

1. Regression toward the mean

People take remedies for colds, aches, indigestion, fatigue and bad nerves. If someone seeks help when they feel worst, a statistical effect called regression toward the mean applies: an extreme measurement is usually followed by one closer to average.

For a seller this is pure gold. A customer takes Antediluvian Tea at their lowest point, improves over the next week, as they might have anyway, and credits the tea. Every remedy sold to people at their lowest benefits from this effect, which is why medicine relies on controlled trials rather than individual experience.

2. Expectation changes how people feel

The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health notes that how a health care provider interacts with a patient may also bring about a positive response.

Springer delivered expectation in bulk. He had a warm radio voice, a confident title of "Doctor," sermons, hymns and a desert oasis with palm trees and mineral baths. NCCIH describes the placebo effect as "a beneficial health outcome resulting from a person’s anticipation that an intervention will help" (NCCIH). For some customers, feeling better was the goal. And this is where the danger lies: a remedy that makes you feel better can keep you away from treatment that actually works.

3. Testimonials beat statistics

One vivid story from a person like you is more persuasive than a table of numbers. Springer's broadcasts and pamphlets ran on this principle, and the Food and Drug Administration still lists it among the warning signs of health fraud: success stories "are easy to make up and are not a substitute for scientific evidence."

Testimonials also carry a hidden bias. You hear from the customers who felt better. People who felt nothing rarely write in, and the seller doesn't read their letters on air. Add confirmation bias, the tendency to notice evidence that supports what you already believe, and a handful of happy letters can feel like proof.

4. One product, many cures

The FDA's first tip off is a product that claims to cure a wide range of diseases. Springer's catalog followed that pattern: one "cocktail" for pep, a laxative tea, salts for the scalp. A cure for everything is really a cure for nothing, but broad promises widen the audience. Everyone has some symptom.

5. Trust borrowed from somewhere else

Springer borrowed authority from three directions:

  • Medicine. He used "Doctor" and a list of degrees that, according to the AMA's Bureau of Investigation, he never earned from any reputable college. See the Fake File.
  • Religion. He was a radio evangelist with hymns, prayers and a chapel at Zzyzx. Questioning the products could feel like questioning the faith.
  • Nature. Desert springs, minerals and herbs sounded wholesome and ancient. The FDA still warns that "all natural" does not necessarily mean safe.

Each layer made skepticism feel rude.

6. Generosity creates obligation

Springer's genius may have been his pricing. His products were offered in exchange for "donations," the Ninth Circuit noted in 1974, prompted by radio appeals, and the resort famously welcomed guests on a sliding scale. Generosity invites reciprocity. A listener who has received free sermons, free songs and maybe a free bus ride to the desert feels a pull to give something back, and a donation to a "humanitarian" mission feels like charity, not a purchase. It also blunts the urge to ask whether the product works. You don't demand a refund from a church.

7. A villain to blame

Brinkley, Baker and Hoxsey all claimed the medical establishment was persecuting them, and the strategy worked so well that Hoxsey's libel win over a magazine article attacking him earned him only $2. The judge reasoned that his promotion depended in part on claims of persecution, so the article had done him no serious damage. See Springer's rivals. When a seller's critics are cast as greedy insiders, every warning becomes evidence that the seller must be onto something.

What the statisticians mean by "it got better"

Regression toward the mean is not a slogan. Adrian G. Barnett, Jolieke C. van der Pols, and Annette J. Dobson described it in the International Journal of Epidemiology in 2005: it is a statistical pattern that can make ordinary variation in repeated measurements look like a real change. Unusually high or unusually low readings tend to be followed by readings closer to the average. The effect gets easier to mistake for a cure when the measurement is noisy, and when you only look again at the people you picked because their first reading was extreme.

That is the shape of a mail-order health business. People write in when they feel worst. A week later many of them feel less worst. The tin gets the credit. Barnett and his coauthors' warning to researchers is the same warning a customer needs: an observed change should always be checked against regression to the mean before anyone calls it an effect. Their paper is about study design, not about Zzyzx. The arithmetic does not care.

What to do before you buy the next tin

This is health advice in the boring sense, and it belongs here because Springer's catalog was a health catalog. The FDA's page on health fraud says that anyone tempted to buy an unproven product, or one with questionable claims, should check with a doctor or other health care professional first. Fraudulent products can waste money and delay diagnosis and proven treatment, and some contain hidden drug ingredients. A label that says "all natural" is no guarantee of safety.

Expectation is real, as the NCCIH definition above makes clear. It is not a reason to skip care that has been tested. NCCIH's clearinghouse does not give medical advice or referrals; a person's own clinician does.

If a product causes a bad reaction, the FDA asks consumers to report it, online or by calling 1-800-FDA-1088. None of that will refund a 1954 donation to Zzyzx. It is the modern version of the question Springer's listeners rarely got to ask the man with the microphone.

Still on the air

Swap the radio for a phone and nothing on this list has changed. The FDA's current tip offs for health fraud read like a review of Springer's career: one product that does it all, personal success testimonials, quick fixes, "all natural" cures and "miracle cure" claims. Its advice is to check with your doctor before you buy.

That's part of why the story of Zzyzx still matters. Springer wasn't a cartoon villain who fooled idiots. He was a skilled performer who understood ordinary people, and he kept it up for decades. Knowing how it worked is the best protection against the next voice on the air.

Sources

Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it.

Cover of The King of Quacks
Kindle preorder

Read the whole story

The King of Quacks is the true story of the radio preacher who claimed a desert, named it the last word in the dictionary and sold it all as a miracle.

About the book

The form opens a message in your own email program to hello@directoryassistancegroup.com. This site does not store the address. See our privacy policy.

More desert history

Desert West

Book trailer

When the Birds Go Silent

The true story of the Mojave War, 1858-1859. Available now on Amazon and wherever books are sold. Visit the book’s site